No. 4

Saturday 31 October 2026

  1. (I’ll Be Glad When You’re Dead) You Rascal You, Louis Armstrong & Louis Jordan
  2. Rein Me In (explicit), Sam Fender & Olivia Dean
  3. I Can’t Make You Love Me, Bonnie Raitt

Happy Halloween, you ghastly aesthetes. Tonight, three songs about love gone wrong. The first one’s the spookiest, and it’s having way more fun than it should.

1 (I’ll Be Glad When You’re Dead) You Rascal You

Louis Armstrong & Louis Jordan, Decca single, 1950, Jazz

It’s fun, it has a wink, yet it’s biting, all at the same time.

Listen for 3:00 Armstrong going past the high C’s for a D.

Louis Armstrong and Louis Jordan are two playful yet debonair leads, and this recording catches them in an impeccable moment. Its energy is quick-witted and wry, but somehow joyful despite the macabre theme; Bill Doggett’s jazz-standard piano stabs punctuate the spoken repartee, and a trumpet obbligato answers the vocals.

The song is a murder ballad about the friend who stole your wife, and the two Louises promise to kill him “just for fun,” since “the bugs can have you when I’m done.” Armstrong turned up to the session with a busted lip, and Jordan remembered that “he even played those high C’s and things with his lip busted.”

Listen on Spotify: (I’ll Be Glad When You’re Dead) You Rascal You or Apple Music: (I’ll Be Glad When You’re Dead) You Rascal You

2 Rein Me In (explicit)

Sam Fender & Olivia Dean, People Watching (Deluxe Edition), 2025, Rock

Three chords, the whole time, and somehow it never gets old.

Listen for 3:55 The outro, where Fender and Dean escape the reins and soar together.

Sam Fender channels Springsteen and Brandon Flowers over a swung jaunt with a lilt, and he plays the bass himself. The bass is his second voice; it talks and walks around the record like it owns the place. And it does.

Fender wrote the song about self-sabotage; he walks a hometown where every flagstone bears the couple’s prints and every memory of her rings like tinnitus. Olivia Dean answers him, rivals him, then meets him, with a verse that insists there’s “nothing brave in walking alone,” and the two of them soar together over a screaming saxophone.

Fittingly for a song about not being able to stop, the duet kept going back to number one in the UK, for a record 23 weeks.

Listen on Spotify: Rein Me In or Apple Music: Rein Me In

3 I Can’t Make You Love Me

Bonnie Raitt, Luck of the Draw, 1991, Pop

She’s longing, but she’s not lonely.

Listen for 2:30 the tension and release on the ii chord at the end of each phrase, with crunchy Rhodes and piano accents.

I Can’t Make You Love Me is a ballad masterclass that escapes its most tiring clichés. You can almost see the smoke sift through the lounge spotlight as Bonnie Raitt goes sultry, resigned to her unrequited lover’s autonomy, yet somehow holding her own with no semblance of weakness. Bruce Hornsby’s piano, the unsung hero of the song, deftly duets her.

Raitt nailed the vocal in one take. The song was so sad, she said later, that she couldn’t find that feeling again, and when they tried for another, she told them, “You know, this ain’t going to happen.”

As a bonus, turn down the lights and listen to Bon Iver’s version, Justin Vernon and Sean Carey leaning into the heartache on dueling grand pianos in AIR Studios.

Listen on Spotify: I Can’t Make You Love Me or Apple Music: I Can’t Make You Love Me

Get next week’s songs.