No. 5

Saturday 7 November 2026

  1. Tender Defender, Vulfpeck feat. Theo Katzman
  2. Check the Rhime, A Tribe Called Quest
  3. Doubting Thomas, Nickel Creek

Happy Saturday. Three songs this week, and two of them peak at 0:55. Serendipity?

1 Tender Defender

Vulfpeck feat. Theo Katzman, Clarity of Cal, 2025, R&B/Soul

It’s sunlight beaming through a window, catching little dust on its way in.

Listen for 2:50 Theo Katzman’s falsetto and sustain, then the backbeat’s reentrance.

That backbeat heartbeat pounds through the whole thing and badum-badums right out of Katzman’s sustained falsetto vibrato.

Its production is somehow light, airy and open, yet punchy, crisp and sticky. Come the end of the bridge, sax and bass lock into a hook with that heartbeat, a groove so tight and satisfying the song bounces in and through a truly delicious chorus.

Listen on Spotify: Tender Defender or Apple Music: Tender Defender

2 Check the Rhime

A Tribe Called Quest, The Low End Theory, 1991, Hip-Hop

Rhythm and bass are the stars of the show, and they shine.

Listen for 0:55 Phife’s verse. His beat-perfect flow is the standout of the track.

Q-Tip and Phife are volleying back and forth at their best in this one, a scurry of swung eighth-note staccato rhymes that sit just a little behind the beat. Perfectly behind the beat.

Drum and bass samples hit loud and deep. Against sampled horns, they give the hook an atonal, disorienting center, so nothing is easy to predict and everything sits ever so uncomfortably in musical space.

Listen on Spotify: Check the Rhime or Apple Music: Check the Rhime

3 Doubting Thomas

Nickel Creek, Why Should the Fire Die?, 2005, Folk & Country

Here, their often-underrated writing gets to shine.

Listen for 0:55 Right after the first chorus, a simple, chime-y hook of interplay with ample space for reflection.

Choosing my first Nickel Creek song for GOODSONGS was an almost insurmountable task. They sit in one of the softest places of my heart.

Everything you’d expect from a Nickel Creek folk ballad is here, from the pitch-perfect harmonies they’ve been stacking together ethereally since they were kids to Chris Thile’s virtuosic mandolin and its interplay with Sara’s fiddle and Sean’s guitar.

So what’s unique here? It’s a song of spiritual searching, of being disoriented and disillusioned, but still somehow, against all odds, hopeful that there’s a true governing good in the world. And it’s told in some of the most painfully beautiful turns of phrase they put to paper in their whole career, like Thile wondering whether he’ll find “a soul-saving love or just the dirt above and below me.”

Listen on Spotify: Doubting Thomas or Apple Music: Doubting Thomas

Get next week’s songs.